Could
a vote to Leave the European Union on June 23rd spell the end of the UK?
It's
a very real potential consequence that doesn't seem to be discussed
much.
The
UK will vote as one country whether to leave the EU, but the UK isn't
one country. What English people decide to do might be different from
what the Scots or Welsh decide.
Hypothetical
situation 1
Let's
say England votes overwhelmingly to Leave the EU (which is entirely
possible), but Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland all vote to
Remain.
But,
because England is the more overwhelmingly populous country, her
votes to Leave outnumbers the combined Remain votes from the latter
three countries? So the entire UK leaves the EU, directly against the decision of the people of 3 of the 4 countries that make up
the UK.
What
then?
There
is certainly a democratic deficit here, and the question really is
whether this deficit might spark a constitutional crisis that could
force the breaking up of the United Kingdom.
Should
the people of, say, Wales, be forced to Leave the EU when the Welsh
people overwhelmingly vote to Remain? Should the Scots or people of
Northern Ireland?
And
this hypothetical situation is a distinct possibility. Consistent
polling shows that by a significant amount the people of Scotland, Wales and Northern
Ireland will vote to Remain, while the UK vote as a whole is
polling at roughly even.
If
this very possible hypothesis is realised, I see another Scottish
independence referendum around the corner, but this time with a
massive YES vote. And with it, moves to speed up the devolution of an
independent Wales.
Northern
Ireland would be more complicated (isn't it
always?), although Sinn Féin is justifiably demanding a referendum in NI on
always?), although Sinn Féin is justifiably demanding a referendum in NI on
Ireland
reunification if the UK Leaves and NI votes to Remain. Which I would
say is fair enough - do the people of NI want to remain with England
outside of the EU, or reunify with Ireland and remain in the EU?
That
would be an interesting discussion.
Now,
an argument against this situation occurring would be that at
General
Elections, Scotland and Wales would rather cut off their collective
hands than ever vote Tory, but under a Tory Government they live due
to accepting the results of the full UK vote, at the 2015 elections
led almost entirely by (largely southern) English votes.
True.
And being ruled by a Tory Government that they didn't vote for is one
of the main arguments that justifies Scotland's claim to
independence.
But
at least people in those non-Tory voting countries and regions can be
represented by an MP and council of their own choosing. Leaving the
EU is all or nothing; we're either all in, or we're all out.
Hypothetical
situation 2
Or,
another hypothetical? What if England narrowly votes to Leave, but
the Remain votes from the Scotland, Wales and NI are so numerous that
they dwarf the English Leave votes. So the UK remains a member of the
EU, but the largest country in the UK voted to leave. What then?
Stronger and maybe more justified calls for an independent English
Parliament, contributing still to a further breakup of UK union?
If
the UK does vote to Leave, it's difficult to see how the union will
stay together.
The
irony here, of course, is that many of the goons that campaigned so
hard for Scotland to reject independence and maintain the United
Kingdom are, by campaigning so vociferously for the UK to leave the
EU, the very same people that could smash the whole thing up.
No comments:
Post a Comment